| 2021 | Nolan Cobb | All-American |
| All-State (1st team) |
| All-Section (1st team) |
| All-Conference |
| Star Trib. All-Metro (1st team) |
| Jake McCarthy | All-State (3rd team) |
| All-Section (1st team) |
| All-Conference |
| Aydan Rathsabandith | All-Section (1st team) |
| All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Gordy Gombold | All-Section (2nd team) |
| All-Conference |
| Cody Ringquist | All-Section (2nd team) |
| All-Conference |
| Matt TenBroek | All-Section (Hon. Mention) |
| All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Academic All-Conference |
| Parker Boone | Academic All-Conference |
| 2020 | No Games Played | |
| 2019 | Benny Henry | All-Section (1st team) |
| All-Conference |
| Nick Hofstad | All-Section (2nd team) |
| All-Conference |
| Sam Wallace | All-Section (2nd team) |
| All-Conference |
| Jake McCarthy | All-Section (2nd team) |
| All-Conference |
| Max Ritchie | All-Section (Hon. Mention) |
| All-Conference |
| Academic All-Conference |
| Carson Jacobs | All-Section (Hon. Mention) |
| All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Aydan Rathsabandith | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Garrett Lowe | Academic All-Conference |
| 2018 | Princeton Oppong | All-State Hon. Mention |
| All-Section (1st team) |
| All-Conference |
| Academic All-Conference |
| Carson Jacobs | All-Section (2nd team) |
| All-Conference |
| Nick Hofstad | All-Section (Hon. Mention) |
| All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Sam Wallace | All-Section (Hon. Mention) |
| All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Davis Bach | All-Section (Hon. Mention) |
| Blake Camuel | All-Section (Hon. Mention) |
| 2017 | Wes Wolfe | All-State Hon. Mention |
| All-Section (1st team) |
| All-Conference |
| Drew Bianchini | All-Section (1st team) |
| All-Conference |
| Princeton Oppong | All-Section (2nd team) |
| All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Blake Camuel | All-Section (Hon. Mention) |
| All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Nick Wallace | All-Section (Hon. Mention) |
| 2016 | Ryan Graff | All-American |
| Academic All-American |
| All-State (1st team) |
| Academic All-State |
| All-Section (1st team) |
| All-Conference |
| Academic All-Conference |
| Star Trib. Metro Player of Year |
| EPOCH - Player of Year |
| Mr. Lacrosse Finalist |
| Andrew Broman | All-State (2nd team) |
| Academic All-State |
| All-Section (1st team) |
| All-Conference |
| Academic All-Conference |
| Weiland Parrish | All-Section (2nd team) |
| All-Conference |
| Justin Higgins | All-Section (2nd team) |
| All-Conference |
| Jack Monssen | All-Section (2nd team) |
| All-Conference |
| Jay Johnson | All-Section (2nd team) |
| All-Conference |
| Academic All-Conference |
| Mike Goedderz | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Luke Graves | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Princeton Oppong | Academic All-State |
| Kyle Thomson | Academic All-State |
| Aaron Malecek | Academic All-Conference |
| 2015 | Ryan Graff | All-American |
| All-State (1st team) |
| All-Section (1st team) |
| All-Conference |
| Nate Buswell | All-American |
| All-State (1st team) |
| All-Section (1st team) |
| All-Conference |
| Academic All-Conference |
| Alex Wilson | All-American |
| All-State (1st team) |
| All-Section (1st team) |
| All-Conference |
| Academic All-Conference |
| Andrew Broman | All-State (2nd team) |
| All-Section (1st team) |
| All-Conference |
| Malik Ekpenyong | All-Section (2nd team) |
| All-Conference |
| Academic All-Conference |
| Connor Norberg | All-Section (2nd team) |
| All-Conference |
| Academic All-Conference |
| Joey Eggleston | All-Section (2nd team) |
| All-Conference |
| Justin Higgins | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Wyatt Johnson | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| 2014 | Ryan Graff | All-American |
| All-State (1st team) |
| All-Section (1st team) |
| All-Conference |
| Nate Buswell | All-State (2nd team) |
| All-Section (1st team) |
| All-Conference |
| Malik Ekpenyong | All-Section (2nd team) |
| All-Conference |
| Andrew Broman | All-Section (2nd team) |
| All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Chris Krammer | All-Section (2nd team) |
| All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Nolan Miles | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| 2013 | Nate Buswell | All-Section (1st team) |
| All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Ryan Graff | All-Section (2nd team) |
| All-Conference |
| Nate Wiklund | All-Section (2nd team) |
| All-Conference |
| Joey Eggleston | All-Section (2nd team) |
| All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Tyler Lundberg | All-Section (2nd team) |
| Malik Ekpenyong | All-Conference |
| Nolan Miles | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| 2012 | Jake Wallace | All-Section (2nd team) |
| All-Conference |
| Nolan Miles | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Jack Tolkinen | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Nate Wiklund | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| 2011 | Justin Woodley | All-Section (1st team) |
| All-Conference (1st team) |
| Nick Roffers | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Jack Straus | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Ryan Weiss | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| 2010 | Justin Woodley | All-State (2nd team) |
| All-Section (1st team) |
| All-Conference (1st team) |
| Eric Alm | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Ty Hakala | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Nick Roffers | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| 2009 | TJ Gallus | All-American |
| All-State (1st team) |
| All-Section (1st team) |
| All-Conference (1st team) |
| Bjorn Knutson | All-American |
| All-State (1st team) |
| All-Section (1st team) |
| All-Conference (1st team) |
| Cody Hendricks | All-State (2nd team) |
| All-Section (1st team) |
| All-Conference (1st team) |
| Max Dupont | All-Section (1st team) |
| All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Nick Ilii | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Wes Jacobson | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Drew Kahl | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| 2008 | Mike Becken | All-American |
| All-State (1st team) |
| All-Conference (1st team) |
| TJ Gallus | All-State (2nd team) |
| All-Conference (1st team) |
| Bjorn Knutson | All-State (2nd team) |
| All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Andrew Straus | All-State (2nd team) |
| All-Conference (1st team) |
| Wes Jacobson | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Cody Hendricks | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| 2007 | Kai Knutson | Academic All-American |
| All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Alex Wesenberg | All-State (2nd team) |
| All-Conference (1st team) |
| Justin Linde | All-State (3rd team) |
| All-Conference (1st team) |
| Andrew Straus | All-State (3rd team) |
| All-Conference (1st team) |
| Mike Becken | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Bjorn Knutson | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| 2006 | Jon Hovey | All-Conference (1st team) |
| Andrew Larson | All-Conference (1st team) |
| Pat McDaniels | All-Conference (1st team) |
| Bill Straus | All-Conference (2nd team) |
| Cole Tolkinen | All-Conference (2nd team) |
| Ben Truong | All-Conference (2nd team) |
| Alex Wesenberg | All-Conference (2nd team) |
| Sam Farrington | All-Conference (3rd team) |
| Mike Greeney | All-Conference (3rd team) |
| Matt Lalim | All-Conference (3rd team) |
| Kenny Cameron | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Justin Linde | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| James Neumann | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Academic All-Conference |
| Andrew Straus | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Mike Becken | Academic All-Conference |
| Kai Knutson | Academic All-Conference |
| 2005 | Jon Hovey | All-Conference (1st team) |
| Andrew Larson | All-Conference (1st team) |
| Joey Olander | All-Conference (1st team) |
| Peter Gerde | All-Conference (2nd team) |
| Bill Straus | All-Conference (2nd team) |
| Davis Zismer | All-Conference (2nd team) |
| David Norine | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Mike Smith | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| Alex Wesenberg | All-Conference (Hon. Mention) |
| James Neumann | Academic All-Conference |
| 2004 | Jake Launert | All-American |
| All-State (1st team) |
| All-Conference (1st team) |
| Bryce Reme | All-American |
| All-State (1st team) |
| All-Conference (1st team) |
| Mike Smith | All-American |
| All-State (1st team) |
| All-Conference (1st team) |
| Drew Fautsch | All-State (2nd team) |
| All-Conference (1st team) |
| Max Mittelstaedt | All-State (2nd team) |
| All-Conference (1st team) |
| Brett Johnson | All-State (3rd team) |
| All-Conference (1st team) |
| Travis Swanson | All-State (Hon. Mention) |
| All-Conference (2nd team) |
| Brandon Creager | All-Conference (2nd team) |
| Academic All-State |
| Joey Olander | All-Conference (2nd team) |
| Davis Zismer | All-Conference (2nd team) |
| Will Yun | Academic All-State |
| 2003 | Andy Haugen | All-State (1st team) |
| State Tourney MVP (overall) |
| Robert Hicks | All-State (1st team) |
| Jake Launert | All-State (1st team) |
| State Tourney MVP (defense) |
| Dan Willman | All-State (1st team) |
| Johnny Erickson | All-State (2nd team) |
| State Tourney MVP (offense) |
| Robbie Meek | All-State (2nd team) |
| Bryce Reme | All-State (2nd team) |
| Zach Brancale | All-State (Hon. Mention) |
| Max Mittelstaedt | All-State (Hon. Mention) |
| 2002 | Jake Launert | All-State (1st team) |
| Robbie Meek | All-State (1st team) |
| Nick VanWagner | All-State (1st team) |
| David Vorpahl | All-State (1st team) |
| 2001 | John Bradley | All-State (1st team) |
| Zach Johnson | All-State (1st team) |
| Ryan VanBockel | All-Star Game MVP (defense) |
| 2000 | Matt Mathiason | All-State (1st team) |
| Chandler Nault | All-State (1st team) |
| Ben Uzlik | State Tourney MVP (offense) |
| Joe Wronka | State Tourney MVP (defense) |
| 1999 | John Bradley | All-State (1st team) |
| Jimmy Haugen | All-State (1st team) |
| Matt Mathiason | All-State (1st team) |
| 1998 | Jared DeWolf | All-State (1st team) |
| Jimmy Haugen | All-State (1st team) |
| Matt Mathiason | All-State (1st team) |